Challace McMillin was the foundational head coach of the James Madison University (JMU) football program, leading the team from its inception in 1972 until 1984. With a record of 67–60–2, McMillin was not only instrumental in establishing JMU’s football team but also significantly contributed to its early success and growth. Notably, under his guidance, the JMU football program achieved its only unbeaten season in 1975 with a 9-0-1 record. McMillin’s tenure is marked by his pioneering spirit and his role in shaping the football program’s initial years, laying the groundwork for future success and a competitive spirit that endures at JMU
Mickey Matthews had a significant impact on JMU football, leading the team to its first Division I-AA (now FCS) National Championship in 2004. His tenure included multiple playoff appearances and a historic win over Virginia Tech in 2010. Matthews was released in 2013 after a 6–6 season and missing the FCS playoffs for the fourth time in five years​.
Everett Withers served as head coach for two seasons, compiling a 19-7 overall record. His tenure featured playoff appearances in both years and national attention when ESPN’s College GameDay showcased the Dukes in 2015
